If you're shopping for speed, switch bats, and a card that won't wreck your stub count, Elly De La Cruz is still worth a look, especially when you compare him against the MLB The Show 26 stubs grind most players face. The Live Series version sits as an 83 OVR Gold, but it plays like a very specific kind of tool: quick, twitchy, and a bit messy at the plate. That sounds rough, yet it's exactly why people keep putting him at shortstop and moving on.
On paper, Elly's live card is not a monster. His contact numbers are fine, not scary. Power is there, but it's more of a "don't sleep on me" thing than a full-on bomb squad vibe. The real story is the speed, the steal rating, and that arm. In-game, those traits matter fast. You feel them on defense, on first-step range, and when he gets on base. At short, he can cover enough ground to stay useful. At DH, though, the bat profile looks a little cleaner, which is why some players treat him like a lineup piece first and a glove second.
That said, his hitting won't carry you by itself. He's balanced, and that's the point. He can hit both sides without becoming a platoon headache. Add in the Reds captain links, and he gets a bit more juice than the raw card suggests. If you run Cincinnati-themed teams, the fit just makes more sense. If not, he's still a cheap speed threat who can steal a bag and annoy the other guy.
1. He turns singles into pressure.
2. His arm saves bad spots.
3. Switch-hitting keeps lineups flexible.
Reality check: He is not a top-tier meta shortstop, so don't expect him to mash like the elite Diamonds.
Version OVR Main path Best use Live Series Elly 83 Marketplace or packs Cheap speed and defense Lightning Elly 94 April Lightning Collection Stronger all-around lineup piece
Someone asked me whether the Live card is still worth it if they already have a decent shortstop.
Yeah, if you want speed, steals, and a low-cost bench bat, he still makes sense.
The cheap route is simple: buy him off the market if the price stays near the low end, or pull him from a pack if you're already ripping packs anyway. The expensive route is chasing the Lightning card, which is a different beast. That 94 OVR version comes from the April Spotlight collection, not the Live Series market, so mixing them up only wastes time. If you're building a Reds squad, the captain boosts make the Live card feel better than the rating says. If you're building pure meta, he's more of a situational fit than an automatic start.
He works best when you want movement on the bases and a body at short who won't collapse defensively. You can bat him near the bottom, let him reach, then let the speed do the annoying work. That's the real value. Not hype, not card art, just a player who can create a run out of nowhere. And if you're checking prices, the cheap MLB The Show 26 stubs is where the live version usually makes the most sense for most squads anyway.